VALAR WATCH
Key findingsTheir claims, annotatedEvidenceTake action
374 facts · 512 sources · updated 2026-09-30

Fact dir-003

newrecordconfirmed The only mineral occurrences on record near Section 28 are road-gravel pits and a CO2 field; by law common gravel cannot be claimed
2026-09-29 · dir-003 · Utah Geospatial Resource Center, Valar Atomics, Carbon County

Utah's mineral occurrence records (the USGS / Utah Geological and Mineral Survey records compiled by UGRC) list six occurrences within about 6 km of Section 28: all are sand-and-gravel pits in pediment gravels (Utah Department of Highways pits 04024, 04025 and 04026 northeast of the Wellington rodeo ground, the Wellington NE and NW gravel pits, and the Soldier Creek upper gravel pits), described as road metal, riprap and aggregate. The CRIB mineral-location layer adds one carbon dioxide occurrence. Federal law says no deposit of common varieties of sand, stone or gravel is a valuable mineral deposit under the mining laws unless it has a distinct and special value (30 U.S.C. 611), and carbon dioxide is obtained by lease, not by claim. No vein or lode deposit of a locatable mineral is on record there in these databases. A lode claim requires a vein or lode discovered within it (Utah Code 40-1-1; dir-004). Absence from these databases does not prove no mineral exists.

In plain termsThe government's mineral records for the area around the claim show only gravel pits for road building, plus some carbon dioxide underground. Ordinary gravel cannot be held with a mining claim, and carbon dioxide is obtained by lease, not by claim. A lode claim is supposed to cover a mineral vein. None is recorded there. That does not prove there is none, but it is the question Valar's claim raises.
verified 2026-09-29: Queried by Claude on 2026-09-29 (envelope about 110.62-110.76 W, 39.53-39.64 N). Correction 2026-09-29 (wording review): lease wording restated. Correction 2026-09-30 (source objectivity review): The State's map layer cited here (Utah Geospatial Resource Center, hosted on ArcGIS Online) was queried on 29 September 2026; that server's robots rules do not allow a saved copy, so none is kept and the figures rest on the cited layer as queried that day.

In tabs: mining, carbon_site · file claude_direct