VALAR WATCH
Key findingsTheir claims, annotatedEvidenceTake action
374 facts · 512 sources · updated 2026-09-30

Fact mine-015

newrecordconfirmed What the Carbon lease allows now (surveys, testing) and what a reactor there would still need (permits with hearings)
2026-08-20 · mine-015 · Utah Trust Lands Administration, Valar Atomics, Carbon County, Utah Division of Water Rights, Utah Department of Environmental Quality, U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission

Per the Trust Lands memorandum and staff remarks: the lease gives Valar 'site control' so it can study the land and start permitting; before any earthwork it may survey the property, do geotechnical testing and cultural-resource inventories. Construction needs a Trust Lands-approved development plan, a reclamation and performance bond, and every federal, state and local permit, including a Carbon County conditional use permit (the land is zoned Mining and Grazing, where large industrial projects are a conditional use; that process requires notice, a public hearing and comment); water rights bought and moved through a Division of Water Rights change application (publicly advertised, open to protest); Utah DEQ water-discharge (UPDES) and air-quality permits with comment periods; and NRC licensing, which the memo calls a public process with Federal Register notice and hearings. Spent fuel may not be stored on trust land: Valar must first buy any part to be used for it. The land now carries easements for fiber-optic lines, a power line and a county road, a grazing permit (to be ended before construction) and a 160-acre Utah National Guard training lease.

In plain termsThe lease is the first step, not the last. Under it, Valar may survey the land, test the soil and rock and look for archaeological sites before any construction, so stakes and markers on the parcel could come from that work. According to the state's memo, before anything is built there must be a county hearing, water-rights notices, and state and federal permits, each with a chance for the public to speak. (Valar's test reactor in Emery County runs under DOE authorization, not an NRC licence, orig-034, so which federal route a Carbon reactor would take is not settled in the records read.)
verified 2026-09-29: Re-read 2026-09-29: memo pp. 25-28 and August transcript (survey, geotechnical, cultural inventories; development plan approval; bond) match; quotes exact. Plain field now attributes the permit list to the memo and notes the DOE-vs-NRC question.

In tabs: carbon_site, process · file mining