VALAR WATCH
Key findingsTheir claims, annotatedEvidenceTake action
374 facts · 512 sources · updated 2026-09-30

Fact safe-011

newanalysisconfirmed DOE's shipping review covers 24 fuel blocks, a third of the 76 fuel elements described: at most 5.64 kg of U-235
2026-05-20 · safe-011 · U.S. Department of Energy, Valar Atomics

The DOE Safety Evaluation Report (safe-010) notes that 'only 24 packages (24 fuel elements)' would be authorized under the amendment, one fuel block per package, each limited to 234.94 grams of U-235: at most about 5.64 kg of U-235 in all (24 x 234.94 g). At an enrichment under 20%, each block carries at least about 1.17 kg of uranium (234.94 g divided by 0.20), so 24 blocks hold roughly 28 kg of uranium or more. Valar's NSDA describes a core of 76 fuel elements with about 250 kg of heavy metal at 4.95%, which is about 12.4 kg of U-235 (250 kg x 4.95%). The authorization expires on 30 June 2027 or when shipments are complete. At the state Trust Lands hearing on 17 September 2026, a Valar speaker described Ward 250 as 'very lightly loaded' and not a fully loaded core (mine-033). Whether other fuel reached Ward 250 by another route is not stated in any record read. Per element, the NSDA's own figures imply 162.83 g of U-235 in 3.29 kg of heavy metal; DOE's block holds 234.94 g of U-235 in 1.18 kg of uranium. No single enrichment fits both (76 such blocks holding 250 kg would need 7.14%), so Table 6's equal per-element loading does not match the block DOE cleared, unless some of the 76 elements are unfueled or loaded differently, which the paper does not say.

In plain termsThe shipping review covers 24 fuel blocks (its term), about a third of the 76 fuel elements the safety agreement describes, with less than half the splitting uranium but up to about four times the richness. That fits the company's own statement that the reactor is running on a partial load. If these 24 blocks are the whole load, the reactor in Utah is not the core the public safety agreement describes: fewer elements, with richer fuel.
verified 2026-09-29: Re-read SER sec. 6 and conditions, NSDA Table 6 on 2026-09-29. Arithmetic re-checked (24 x 234.94 g = 5.64 kg; 234.94/0.20 = 1.17 kg U per block; 250 kg x 4.95% = 12.4 kg). Headline no longer says DOE 'approved shipping' (the SER recommends the amendment); plain hedged because other fuel routes are unknown. Correction 2026-09-29 (calculation audit): headline says '76 fuel elements' (not blocks); detail adds the per-element comparison. Correction 2026-09-29 (wording review): plain uses 'fuel elements' for the NSDA and 'block' only for DOE's shipping review.

In tabs: safety, operations · file safety