VALAR WATCH
Key findingsTheir claims, annotatedEvidenceTake action
374 facts · 512 sources · updated 2026-09-30

Fact safe-017

newrecordconfirmed Worker safety: OSHA rules instead of DOE's worker rule; two licensed-style operators a shift; radiation tech on call
2025-10 · safe-017 · Valar Atomics, U.S. Department of Energy, DOE Idaho Operations Office

The NSDA's code of record lists DOE's worker safety and health rule, 10 CFR 851, as 'N/A', replaced by OSHA standards (29 CFR 1910/1926) under the contractor-owned model; a second table gives its applicability as 'Phased' and notes a 'DOE Idaho Operations Office exemption request in process for construction activities' pending a revision of 10 CFR 851, and Appendix C.4 says the OSHA approach for the construction phase was 'approved through the OTA' (Valar's statement; no DOE record of it was read). DOE-STD-1271, for its part, says that in some instances, such as worker industrial safety, DOE authorization is exempted from OSHA requirements. Neither document says which agency inspects or enforces worker safety at Ward 250 if DOE's rule is set aside and OSHA's own requirements do not reach a DOE-authorized facility. Radiation protection stays under DOE's rule 10 CFR 835 (occupational limit 5 rem a year), per the NSDA and the categorical exclusion. Minimum staffing in the NSDA: one Senior Reactor Operator and one Reactor Operator per shift, a 'Radiation Protection Technician: On-call', plus a facility director, a technical support engineer and a maintenance technician. Operators are qualified under the ANS-15.4 research-reactor standard instead of DOE's review (Appendix C.2); no NRC operator licences are involved, though Valar's documents call them 'licensed operators'. Valar's QA program says its Radiation Safety Lead function 'may be fulfilled by qualified USREL personnel under appropriate agreements'; the state lab advertised for its own Safety Manager in September 2026 (dir-006). Whether DOE granted the 10 CFR 851 exemption, and what applies to workers after construction, is not in any DOE record read.

In plain termsWorkers at DOE sites are usually covered by DOE's own safety rule; Valar asked to use ordinary OSHA workplace rules instead, with DOE's radiation-exposure rule still applying. The plan calls for two qualified operators per shift and a radiation-protection technician who is on call rather than on site. Operators are trained to a research-reactor standard by the company, not licensed by the NRC. Some radiation-safety duties may be done by staff of the state lab.
verified 2026-09-29: Re-read NSDA pp. 25, 45, 48, 54-55, QAPD pp. 9-10, DOE-STD-1271 sec. 4 and CX p. 5 on 2026-09-29. Holds. Added the NSDA's 'Phased' applicability and its claim that the OSHA approach for construction was 'approved through the OTA'. 'Licensed operators' and 'duly licensed Senior Reactor Operator' confirmed in the QAPD.

In tabs: safety, operations · file safety